Zeta Channel Rules • FAQ • Search • advertise
General Statistics
Total Posts: 269107
Total Topics: 4548
Online Today: 24
Online Ever: 127, on March 13, 2007, 12:56:10 PM
Users Online
Totals
Users: 7
Guests: 11
Total: 18
Index
» Debate » Border Patrol: Above the Constitution of the United States?
 Pages: [1]
thedrunkenmonkey    Topic opened August 04, 2008, 02:12:06 PM
Renown: +110/-14
Offline Offline

Posts: 1,906

Inebriated Simian (Skype: thedrunkenmonkey)
So, as I've read the latest information coming out of the US Border Patrol policy, US customs agents are now authorized by the Border Patrol to seize cellphones, laptops, computers, and hard drives, and copy the contents of the drives, hold onto the contents,  and automatically review all materials on the computers regardless of the 4th and 5th Amendments. I'm not sure of the legality of this policy, but since it's been in effect since 2006, I'm not seeing any fast changes.

http://www.thetransnational.travel/news.php?cid=laptop-seizure.Jul-08.09

So. Thoughts? Apparently the Bush administration has called a laptop "no different from any other closed container".

Though personally I do wonder if the Bush administration believes that to be true of any of their own computers and/or email systems.
Logged
You are TOO my monkey.
Coani Reply #1 in Border Patrol: Above the Constitution of the United States? — Posted August 04, 2008, 02:43:58 PM
Renown: +9/-0
Offline Offline

Posts: 774
I understand and accept a lot of the security measures in place.  I'm ok with Border Patrol taking a quick scan through my pictures to make sure I'm not photographing things that put them in direct danger.  I'm ok with turning on my laptop to prove that it's not a bomb.  I'm not ok with them having a copy of everything on my computer.  Especially to hold indefinitely.  Without probable cause.

I don't like it on several levels.
First, I like my 4th and 5th Amendment Rights just as much as the 19th.  When I joined the military in 1999 it was to protect my country and uphold our values and rights.  It pisses me off to see the things I joined to defend being raped, especially since I can't do a damn thing to stop it.

Second, I know too many people who have banking information on their computer.  All it takes is one less-than-scrupulous Border Patrol Guy to make a copy of certain files, or lose the hard drive they're stored on, and the government will, once again, be responsible for a round of identity theft. 

Third, they don't even have to give a reason "Because I said so" shouldn't apply once you move out of your parents' house.

Grr!
Logged
Cthulhu hugs make everything better.
Badger Reply #2 in Border Patrol: Above the Constitution of the United States? — Posted August 04, 2008, 02:51:07 PM
Renown: +169/-8
Offline Offline

Posts: 2,517

Swift as a deer, size of a dog, head like a monkey
*makes mental note to load up virus-ridden laptop and make a couple dozen border crossings with it*
Logged
""We can categorically state that we have not released man-eating badgers into the area." - UK military spokesman Major Mike Shearer
Barefoot Priestess
jabbaciv Reply #3 in Border Patrol: Above the Constitution of the United States? — Posted August 04, 2008, 04:43:07 PM
All Klingon in the Pants
Renown: +68/-15
Offline Offline

Posts: 5,281

We can't stop here, this is bat country
Quote from: Coani on August 04, 2008, 02:43:58 PM
First, I like my 4th and 5th Amendment Rights just as much as the 19th.  When I joined the military in 1999 it was to protect my country and uphold our values and rights.  It pisses me off to see the things I joined to defend being raped, especially since I can't do a damn thing to stop it.

Same boat as me.
Logged
Don't confuse a position that is both a logically and morally defensible one with dogma.
"The laws and Constitution are designed to survive, and remain in force, in extraordinary times." -SCOTUS Justice Kennedy
phobos Reply #4 in Border Patrol: Above the Constitution of the United States? — Posted August 04, 2008, 04:55:16 PM
Free Range Moderator
Renown: +58/-2
Offline Offline

Posts: 2,698
Note to self: if ever I have to enter the US under the current regime, make sure that all my internet bookmarks are to somethingorother.on.nimp.org so as to give them something interesting to look at.

(edit: in case it's not obvious from context and from the fact I didn't make it a link - that's not a good site to visit. Any URL ending in 'on.nimp.org' is thermonuclear internet hell that can never be un-seen. Having Noscript installed is a very good idea.)
Last Edit: August 04, 2008, 04:58:29 PM by phobos Logged
Jar-Jar, you're a genius!

Wii: 0349 5934 4001 0024
12595_mr._tester.png
Symmetry Reply #5 in Border Patrol: Above the Constitution of the United States? — Posted August 04, 2008, 07:06:13 PM
Renown: +3/-0
Offline Offline

Posts: 739

安堵竜
I'm afraid its worse than that phobos.  Customs agents have been able to search pretty much anything they want at a border crossing for a long time, its only the confiscation of laptops policy that's changed.  I seem to recall right-wingers using border searches as a way to try to prove that Clinton was turning the US into a police state, back in the day.

We've been fighting the War on DrugsTM for a lot longer than the War on TerrorTM and I think that the former has actually done a lot more to hurt civil liberties within the US than the later.
Logged
'Because ten billion years' time is so fragile, so ephemeral... it arouses such a bittersweet, almost heartbreaking fondness.'
Aeryven Reply #6 in Border Patrol: Above the Constitution of the United States? — Posted August 04, 2008, 07:34:00 PM
Mad William Bonney
I've donated. Why haven't you?
Renown: +52/-6
Online Online

Posts: 2,883
And people look at me like I'm crazy when I say I'm afraid to go across the border into the US. Honestly, I just don't want to deal with the potential hassle of going into a country where I essentially have no rights as soon as I hit the border. (Don't bother telling me I do have rights there. My government couldn't do squat if yours decided it wanted to keep me.)

At least as Americans, you still have SOME rights in the US. I'm a nasty, dirty foreigner who's obviously bent on sneaking into your country, killing your pets and children, and stealing your McJobs! OH NOES! I have a beach towel in my suitcase! I couldn't POSSIBLY be on vacation from a country you don't respect! I must be a TERRORIST AS WELL!

Fuck. That. Shit.

Keep your country. Keep your borders. I promise I won't cross either one if I can at all help it.
You may call that paranoia.. but I call it being smart and playing it safe.


Um...

...did that come off as a tad bit snarky?  Huh?
Logged
-- Iuvante Bardus Ignarus --
Club Nowhere Chat! - Now online and awaiting chatters!
Will's OfficeCam! - Soon, you will be able to watch me work! Huzzah!
machiavelli33 Reply #7 in Border Patrol: Above the Constitution of the United States? — Posted August 04, 2008, 07:51:05 PM
Game Master
Renown: +48/-4
Offline Offline

Posts: 3,045

Not your typical chinaman.
Not really.

Haha, McJobs.
Logged
"Wasn't until years later we found out what fag -really- meant."
"-You're- a fag."
"No no...a fag's a cigarette...remember?"
"-You're- a cigarette."
8833_mr._gm.png
da chicken Reply #8 in Border Patrol: Above the Constitution of the United States? — Posted August 04, 2008, 09:41:04 PM
Renown: +131/-15
Offline Offline

Posts: 5,786

It's a joke. Laugh.
Don't fuck with me.  I've read Douglas Adams.  I know what you Commonwealth folk can do with towels.
Logged
"Quotation is a serviceable substitute for wit." -- Oscar Wilde

"If you want to make an apple pie from scratch, you must first create the universe." -- Carl Sagan
89649_mr._bugfinder.png12595_mr._tester.png
NoxEquites Reply #9 in Border Patrol: Above the Constitution of the United States? — Posted August 05, 2008, 01:08:14 AM
Renown: +37/-1
Offline Offline

Posts: 3,555

I make shiny things, you need them.
The problem is that government agencies make up regulations and enforce them as laws. Remember you can only sue the government if the government lets you.
Logged
I have shinies you want. http://kinshar.dreamhosters.com/
Aeryven Reply #10 in Border Patrol: Above the Constitution of the United States? — Posted August 05, 2008, 11:22:16 AM
Mad William Bonney
I've donated. Why haven't you?
Renown: +52/-6
Online Online

Posts: 2,883
Quote from: da chicken on August 04, 2008, 09:41:04 PM
Don't fuck with me.  I've read Douglas Adams.  I know what you Commonwealth folk can do with towels.
LOL
Logged
-- Iuvante Bardus Ignarus --
Club Nowhere Chat! - Now online and awaiting chatters!
Will's OfficeCam! - Soon, you will be able to watch me work! Huzzah!
thedrunkenmonkey Reply #11 in Border Patrol: Above the Constitution of the United States? — Posted August 05, 2008, 01:02:12 PM
Renown: +110/-14
Offline Offline

Posts: 1,906

Inebriated Simian (Skype: thedrunkenmonkey)
The irony is, I actually have a thing that allows a user with a laptop travel internationally with nothing but a blank laptop. Or, conversely, I can have laptops shipped back and forth across the country, and access information securely online.

The thing is, I don't like the idea that my person is subject to the whims of the US government when I cross the border into another country. I don't like the idea that I only have my personal rights when I live in the US. I check out. I am licensed to carry a concealed firearm in Washington State. My prints are all on file. I fit no profiles of dangerous individuals. So if my stuff gets searched/sequestered, I should have the RIGHT to know why my personal possessions are under quarantine.

I also don't have much of a problem with requesting someone who opens my laptop to sign an NDA that is 20 pages long.
Logged
You are TOO my monkey.
Index
» Debate » Border Patrol: Above the Constitution of the United States?
 Pages: [1]
  |  Reply